On the morning of 10 March, the auditorium of the Mário Soares and Maria Barroso Foundation in Lisbon filled up for a public hearing devoted to the social economy. The title was ambitious — “The Social Economy in Times of Uncertainty – What Political Choices for the Present and Future of the Sector?” — but what was really at stake was something quite concrete: the future of CASES, the António Sérgio Cooperative for the Social Economy.
The room was full. Most of those present were middle-aged or older; there were very few young people. This was hardly surprising. In Portugal, the social economy remains, to a large extent, a territory occupied by those who have been involved in it for many years — association leaders, cooperative members, professionals and people who have devoted much of their lives to this institutional world, which is often invisible to the general public.
Among those present were also members of the Uma Boa Questão cooperative. Like many other organisations in the sector, they were there not only to listen to the debate, but also to make their presence felt. At a time when the future of the social economy was being discussed, being in the room was also a way of affirming the importance of cooperativism and the collective work that many of these organisations carry out on the ground.
The reason for the gathering was the Government's decision to withdraw the State from CASES. For those who follow the sector, this is a change whose consequences are difficult to predict. Since its creation, CASES has operated as a link between the State and the world of cooperatives, associations, foundations and other non-profit organisations — an institutional space that coordinates public policies, supports organisations in the sector and produces knowledge about the social economy in Portugal.
Established in 2009 as a public-interest cooperative, CASES brings together the State and several representative organisations from the social economy in a partnership model that is relatively unusual in Portuguese public administration. Its responsibilities include the accreditation and supervision of cooperatives, the production of statistics and studies on the sector, the promotion of volunteering, the training and capacity-building of organisations, and the provision of technical and legal support to social economy entities. Within an ecosystem made up of thousands of institutions — cooperatives, associations, mutual societies and social solidarity organisations — CASES has, over the years, come to play a role in coordination and mediation.
Cooperativism itself, moreover, is based on a particular approach to economic activity: organisations democratically managed by their members, guided not simply by profit but by social, community-based or collective-interest objectives. In this context, coordinating structures such as CASES help ensure institutional recognition, a legal framework and dialogue with the State.
Throughout the morning, several people connected to the sector took the floor. Some spoke about the importance of cooperative certification, others about CASES's role in producing data and statistics, while others highlighted the training and technical support the organisation provides to its members. A common thread ran through the contributions: the belief that the disappearance — or hollowing out — of this structure would leave a void that would be difficult to fill.
Among those present were also employees of the institution itself. Some contributions made it clear that the concern was not merely institutional or abstract. For those who work there, the discussion has a very concrete dimension: the future of the organisation and of the people who pursue their professional lives within it.
For much of the session, the atmosphere was relatively calm, almost technical. There was talk of legal frameworks, institutional models and the importance of the social economy in a country where cooperatives, associations and social solidarity organisations play a significant role in responding to social needs.
There were moments when the pace of the contributions became somewhat slow — the kind of moments when the fatigue of a long morning begins to set in and attention starts to wander. I confess that, at one point, I found myself discreetly fighting off sleep.
Until politics itself entered the picture.
When a Member of Parliament from the Socialist Party took the floor, the atmosphere in the room changed. Suddenly, mobile phones were raised, cameras appeared and photographs began to be taken. The debate took on a different intensity.
In his speech, the MP promised to defend the State's continued involvement in CASES and to oppose the decision to withdraw. His promise was received with attention — and perhaps with some hope — by an audience clearly concerned about the direction things were taking.
The scene was revealing in its own way. A meeting organised to discuss the future of the social economy briefly turned into a small political stage. The sector was looking for institutional answers, while party politics inevitably emerged as the arena in which these decisions are ultimately contested.
And yet, there was also a feeling that was harder to explain. As though many of the people in that room were searching for something — answers, assurances, perhaps simply dialogue — without being certain that anyone on the other side of the decision-making process was genuinely willing to listen.
As I watched the session, it was difficult not to think about a recurring pattern in Portuguese political life. A government makes a decision that provokes a reaction and opposition. An opposition party then comes forward promising to correct the mistake. Later, when the political roles are reversed, the cycle tends to repeat itself.
Decision, reaction, correction. And then, another decision.
Caught in the middle of this pendulum-like movement are often the institutions — and the people who work in them.
The public hearing on the social economy therefore left a curious impression. On the one hand, it revealed a sector that is mobilised and concerned about its future. On the other, it showed how these discussions inevitably become entangled in the realm of political competition.
Outside the auditorium, the debate is also continuing through other channels. A petition addressed to the Assembly of the Republic is currently circulating, calling for the revocation of the decision to withdraw the State from CASES and for a process of dialogue with the social economy sector to be opened before any institutional restructuring takes place. The initiative can be viewed and signed on Parliament's civic participation platform:
https://participacao.parlamento.pt/initiatives/5835
As I left, it was difficult not to notice the quiet irony of the venue. The debate had taken place at the Mário Soares and Maria Barroso Foundation, an institution that preserves the memory of one of the central figures of Portuguese democracy, Mário Soares. For some, he is an unmistakable symbol of democratic nation-building; for others, a leading figure in a turbulent period of recent history, including the complex process of Portuguese decolonisation.
Perhaps that is why the atmosphere that morning was marked by a feeling that was difficult to define — a mixture of concern and uncertainty. Ultimately, not unlike Portugal's own political history: a history of advances, corrections and debates that seem to return in cycles, always accompanied by new urgencies and the same fundamental questions.
Nuno Chainho Amiar
https://participacao.parlamento.pt/initiatives/5835